Holley vs. Sally

Not all the time, what about President’s or a family member.

I like Sally more than Holley (but i like her too.) Her posh accent annoyed me a little bit.

Saying this on Pixar Planet Forums, sickens me but… I have a major dislike of Sally. Sorry to all you Sally Fans, but to me she just came off as annoying and I feel she is too mature for McQueen in a sense…

I’m not a huge Sally fan either. She used to really annoy me whole bunches. 8D Not anymore, now she’s kind of “eh”. Love Holley.

Yes, I am very “eh” towards her too. I like Holley, but she lacked something, like so many things in that film.

I like how Holley Shiftwell seemed to be Mater’s counterpart of “Don’t care what you look like, just love who you are”, physically and personality-wise. She’s very gentle, the perfect blend of beautiful and intelligent. If only I were Mater, he’s one lucky truck :laughing: . I like her occasional sass and how she and Mater valued their dents. Maybe she’s not the best female love interest, but her part was good enough for me and I’m surprised that I truly love the film as much as I do.

I think Sally has a good role in the first film and I’m glad she at least showed up in the second one. Sally is probably a similar case I have to Bo Peep, someone I thought Toy Story 3 lacked. I love them, but I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that Woody and Lightning McQueen can be happy to have a nice, pleasant (if common) girlfriend. Sure, many of the other Pixar females are stronger, but I feel like they do bring a gentle warmth to the movies when the main characters are too stressed out. Plus, if anything, maybe they make the Jessie’s, Elastigirl’s, and Holley Shiftwell’s all stand out that much more. I don’t know. 8D

I do like both but I would have to say I like Sally better. I cant really say why either. Maybe I just find her to be more believable, I’m not sure.

She needed more personality. She could have had more depth to her dialogue. That said, I appreciate and love what we do know of her. I have a die cast of her(I collect the die casts), and a rubber eraser shaped and colored like her, so I guess to an extent I have a tiny collection of her. Even though Sally has more character, I prefer what we do see of Holly.