I think you have a very bright future as a thesis-writer, nintendo. Very good points raised, and I’d just like to add my two cents worth:
[spoil]The point about Hiccup and Toothless sharing a deeper bond and hence better coordination than their friends totally makes sense, something which I also noticed during my repeat viewing.
As for why the other dragons were so willing to go along with Hiccup’s friends, that can be explained. If you watch Hiccup’s third encounter with Toothless (the one where they share a fish), you can see he tries to distance and dissociate himself from the “other Vikings” (leaving the shield behind, dropping his weapon, bringing an olive branch, or rather a fish). Once he has established himself as a non-threat, Toothless instantly warms up to him. He tries the same trick with the Monstrous Nightmare, but was unfortunately interrupted by Stoick. When he tries the second time, he intentionally leads the Nightmare to Snotloud, and by association, the dragon realizes Hiccup’s friends are also non-enemies. The other dragons have all been ‘tamed’ by Hiccup, as seen in the various montages, so naturally, they accept Hiccup’s friends too.
As already mentioned, I also like how Hiccup had to proactively win over Toothless. Granted, it was a little too convenient seeing Toothless is essentially a wild (but very intelligent) animal whose kind has never been domesticated before, and the progression of their relationship in ‘Forbidden Friendship’ was a little fast, but I guess that’s what makes it all the more amazing, that had their kind not been at war with each other, they would’ve actually been fast friends.
I also think Hiccup may understand English. It’s no coincidence he followed the dragons to the Green Death’s island, again something I noticed on a rewatch. When Astrid whispers to Hiccup about killing his first dragon, Toothless instantly reacts and decides to reveal to his friends the true reason behind the dragons’ raids by changing course. Maybe some viewers would’ve been picked this up the first time, but I didn’t, and it was a revelation that Hiccup has an impressive human vocabulary, or at least is a great reader of body language.[/spoil]
…
For my second and last theatrical viewing, I thought it fitting to send Dragons off on its final screening at the “biggest IMAX cinema in the world”, the LG Imax Theatre at Darling Harbour. It is was a much more pleasant experience than my first because the crowd was bigger (it was a public holiday, and there were more families among the audience), I went alone (my friends kept talking for my first viewing) and of course, it’s freakin’ 3D IMAX. Actually to be honest, they cheated a bit, since it was not shot using Imax dimensions, it was letterboxed, so only like four-fifths of the screen was used. It is still pretty big, but it didn’t exactly stretch from floor to ceiling like I imagined it to.
Once again, the action sequences are simply breathtaking on the big screen. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, you simply have to watch this at least once in the cinema to fully appreciate the fight and battle scenes. No doubt this has something to do with Roger Deakins’ lighting and the direction of whoever is the cinematographer (who I would really like to know and shake his/her hand); you really feel like you’re swooping and floating in the skies. Coupled with John Powell’s grand orchestral soundtrack, and it’s simply sublime.
Again, I’ll be frank and say that the glasses kinda ‘muddied’ the image and sometimes you can see ghost images if you’re not looking at it point blank (I was lucky enough to have a seat in the middle last row, but even then the intersections are not perfect). I think the theatre used ‘RealD’ technology, so something to bear in mind for future viewers.
But other than these minor annoyances, it was a fantastic experience to relive the adventure again, and unlike Up and like Avatar, it really does deserve the 3D treatment. I haven’t been this impressed by an animated film since… Wall-E, actually. Really, I don’t know why. Up, Ratatouille, and all the greats may be more intellectual than Dragons, but this Dreamworks number just stole my heart and ran a home run with it. I absolutely love it, and it’s currently soaring among my favourite films of all-time.