I think the idea of ‘draining happiness’ is a bit too fantasy for me. I’m not keen on that idea. They are SPREADING laughter. It woyuldn’t make much sense to me.
Personally I see the risks primarily at first involving the Monster World. Getting a laugh takes longer then getting a scream if you want to be technical about it. Hence they are more likely to be caught by parents. Plus parents will probably find it weird for kids to be ‘woken up’ LAUGHING. A change will possibly also be noticed.
Plus on the pratical side- jokes are more likely to fall FLAT.
You can use the same routine on a kid or a very similar one in scream collection. The same joke gets stale more quickly.
There are potential problems with laughter there. Getting a laugh out of msomeone is more DIFFICULT then getting a scream. Plus, there is more potential WORKERS for screaming then laughter. What I mean to say is, since laughter is 10 times the energy there will still, even with the increased time per kid taken into account perhap, be a significant drop in employment in that area. Granted in the long term there could be an employment boom much late in other areas (decreased energy costs for other businessses can equal happy times in that area eventually)- but in the short term if they convert everything (probably have yet to do that) people will not be happy. Plus, less people are probably suited for laughter collection versus scaring in terms of the various talents if you get my drift.
I’m more worried about the older scarers then any students myself. The students are still young. They can still retrain, yeah it sucks, but they’re hardly the group in the worst situation at all or the ones who would need the most help,still have their lives ahead of them, but what about the much older scarers? Who’ve been doing it for decades? Some problems there.
The impact Sulley could have on Boo is debateable. I see Boo as being very friendly and inquisitive as she is in the movie, I see that remaining, but heck she’s two and a half so that might change.
Granted, I could see it go the OTHER way. Boo has many friends. She tells them about the monster world (she’s a KID remember, she’s unlikely to know to keep it a secret unless someone tells her and even if she’s a much older kid then she’d possibly let it slip. Possibly.). Most parents see it as harmless fantasy depending on their age… but then something happens (maybe to Boo and/or one of her friends?)
Negative impacts could include if in this next escapade, Boo uses violence AGAIN to deal with the problem. She won’t remember the first movie events but if that sort of thing continues to be a regular thing in their adventures throughout her life, it would be a negative impact on her.
Not to mention I personally see Monsters in her life even eventually making her into a little ‘liar’ if she DOES undrestand the implications of why keeping things under wraps is best. A truth twister. Granted a part of me finds that idea a bit funny given that Sulley is so BAD at it (and Randall too potentially when backed into a corner with his fronds).
Granted if they keep her the same age (hello logical inconsistency) or make her parents extremely abusive (where is the evidence of THAT?) I will NOT be happy over what they’ve done to Boo at all.