Just wanted to say that I saw your list and it’s quite good!
I’ll be happy if Brave is anywhere above Cars on my list, because I know it will be difficult to make it to the top 5.
Here’s my list again. Not sure if it’s changed but it often does anyway. I bolded the top 5 films because they’re all sort of in a tie and I love them all for different reasons, so they’ve been first place at one time or another.
What’s funny is that out of those top 5, I would say Ratatouille has the most flaws, which I see as awkward moments of humor or the script which don’t come through, or perhaps a somewhat weak side character, but there are too many things in the film that go above and beyond standard animation fare. I honestly wonder what children would appreciate in such a mature film! I connect so much to the “Anyone can…” philosophy and the theme of passion in the film, and additionally so much of the score, visuals, lighting, etc. are so stunning I still watch this film in wonder after 5 years. I’m so attached to it that I have a hard time putting it below first place, even though I initially deemed it middle-of-the-road.
1. Ratatouille
2. The Incredibles
3. Up
4. Toy Story
5. Monsters Inc.
6. Toy Story 2
7. Toy Story 3
8. WALL-E
9. Finding Nemo
10. A Bug’s Life
11. Cars
12. Cars 2
My classification? Quite simply: 1. All of them thus far
Sorry, but my love of Pixar is so great that I can’t even begin to number them in any sort of order as to how much I love one compared to another. Sometimes if I feel like I have to slim it down, I admit I kind of have a thing for all of the Toy Story movies, all of the Cars movies, and WALL-E in particular… but then I think about the other 6 films and I’m like, “Well, I’m not about to leave them out!” and thus, I’m back to loving them all to the same extent. I know I’m weird in the way that I have trouble picking favorites of anything (Just ask me what my favorite non-Pixar films are, or my favorite food, or my favorite singer, and I won’t have a straight answer except maybe “all of the following equally”)… but that’s just me
Here’s my updated list: 1. All of them thus far(Including Brave, of course! )
If any of you are intersested in my really deep thoughts about Brave and how completely awesome it is, I’ll write a review somewhere and link you all to it when I can! Returns to practicing her Scottish accent/Imitation of Merida
1.Up
2. Ratatouille
3. WALL-E
4. Brave
5. Toy Story 3
6. The Incredibles
7. Cars 2
8. Toy Story 2
9. Cars
10. Finding Nemo
11. Monsters Inc
12. Toy Story
13. A Bug’s Life
I might see Brave again this weekend, so I’ll have a better opinion of the film. I’ll probably revise it again later.
You guys are making me excited!!! I really hope Brave can be my new favorite since The Incredibles. I don’t know, I just have a really great feeling about this movie.
01 WALL*E
02 The Incredibles
03 Ratatouille
04 Toy Story 2
05 Up
06 Finding Nemo
07 Brave
08 Toy Story 3
09 A Bug’s Life
10 Monsters, Inc.
11 Toy Story
12 Cars
13 Cars 2
As some have brought up, and I brought up in my video review:[url]- YouTube
… I just think that all Pixar movie’s thus far are a work of art, there isn’t one that is bad. However, if I had a gun to my head and he new my thoughts and feelings it would probably be this:
Toy Story Trilogy (Can’t separate them)
Wall-E
The Incredible’s
Monster’s Inc.
Ratatouille
Finding Nemo
Cars
A Bug’s Life
Up
Brave
Cars 2
But again, it’s not like as you go down the list I start hating them more and more. It’s just if I had to choose.
I don’t really have a favorite Pixar film anymore since I think they’re all different and unique in their own ways. My list is only rated in terms of overall quality.
)
