…My review…
First up, a big thank you to Thomas and PixarVixen for hoisting Radio Pixar out of its slump, and back onto the airwaves.
I know it must have been a big task to get into the swing of things again, especially as I’m sure you have your own lives going on in the background. It would have taken quite a bit of resolve to tackle the task of getting Radio Pixar back on track, and going over all of the topics that were sadly missed during the down time and seeing what should be put to air. Give both of yourselves a pat on the back, as well as anyone else behind the scenes who was involved with the program.
How long did it take to get it up and running, by the way? I mean it was delayed for six months + and the podcast material seems pretty up-to-date so I’m guessing after all of that procrastination it wouldn’t have taken that much time to get it going again as you probably thought it might have. Just an observation.
Now about the video podcast… I think it’s an interesting idea and I can already think of some opportunities that could be used with this medium. For now, I think it is still on the developmential side, and you can tell that making a video to match the podcast, was more of an afterthought. But I liked looking at the pretty pictures and the shots of Upcoming Pixar being surfed around on were used to great effect to demonstrate the merger.
I liked how you showed the Ratatouille teaser and WALL●E trailer on its own before talking about them. It gave the podcast more of a TV show type of feeling, and was using the video format to its advantage.
As to whether or not you guys should continue doing the video thing - it’s up to you. Just thinking about it, it would be hard to make a podcast that worked just as well in either format. I think in the end, one format would suffer unless you did a lot of planning beforehand. Does that make sense?
I agree with you guys totally in regards to the Academy Awards. Shrek the Third doesn’t have any heart, and will not be a classic film like Ratatouille. But that’s a no-brainer. And talk about all of the awards it’s nominated for - hearing them all read out gives me a new perspective to how well it is doing.
About the Ratatouille DVD release: Well, you’ve read my opinion on that matter. And I know that many others feel the same way so hopefully someone from Pixar will listen to it, or even come and visit the forums afterwards to see what we think of its shameful one-disc release.
It was good hearing you both hosting the show, because it gave it a bit of a different flavour, and I hope you team up again. I’m sure you guys will be able to build up more confidence in talking to each other and playing off each other. It was also good to hear you taking turns and having a conversation, instead of just talking, talking, talking by the same person, which is what is usually done with Radio Pixar. You should try and keep this format.
…Suggestions…
— I know this isn’t a typical Radio Pixar podcast and the format is different, but next time you should definitely keep the conversational tone of the show, but also invite some different people into the show giving their perspective on a certain aspect of Pixar. It will make the show a lot fresher as well as bring new ideas to the table.
I can think of a handful of people that have passion for their particular Pixar niche, and would be quite capable of creating a video or audio segment based on it. Even if you gave a few of us a trial run over the course of a few shows.
— More of an interaction between the forum and the show. Since the forums are “where it’s at” and most of the fan’s reactions to something Pixar-related are gauged from the forums, it should be paraphrased on the show. A good time to do this would have been during the Ratatouille DVD segment, even if you picked out a couple of members who had an opinion on the subject and had given the opinion airtime.
Doing this would promote the forum to non-forum members who listen to the podcast as a place where active and in-depth discussion of Pixar topics take place, as well as give us members a feeling of having our opinions recognised and broadcast elsewhere. Basically, there should be more of an interconnectivity between the forums and the show - not so much of a one-sided thing. We talk - you listen. That’s it. End of story. Because that’s how it feels to me.
Anyway, what do you guys think of these suggestions, particularly PixarVixen? I also have a lot more ideas to bring to the show that I would love to share. If you would like to talk to to me about them, just private message me.
…Wrap UP!..
Overall, it was an interesting show to say the least. I like how a different format was chosen for the catch up show, and I applaud the effort. With a bit more polishing and practise the video podcast, if it were used to its full potential, could be something quite special.
Personally, I think I would rather see/hear a seperate Radio Pixar podcast, and then a separate Video Pixar podcast. But if you guys can work out a way to juggle both formats and make them work just as well into one podcast, go for it. I can’t wait for the next Radio Pixar.
Oh, and what did everyone else think of hearing an Australian on the show? I can’t tell the difference since I’m quite acquainted with the accent…
Maybe it was such good news that it was worth mentioning twice.
Yay. I’m famous!