True enough SoA and fair point, though I’d hesitate to say all four of their sequels totally sucked.
Let’s see:
Shrek 2: Good. Really good. Lauded as better than the original in fact. (Though personally I prefer the former, but this is rather like me and TS3- lots of people seem to think its better than the predecessors but I personally disagree despite liking it overall- ah well)
Madagascar 2: Not exactly horrifying, but really mediocre and felt like a parody of The Lion King. The antagonist was terrible. Though I guess it’s okaaay if you just want to vegetate on the sofa or something if you’ve no other choice. But not something I’d go out of my way to choose it. (Plus I’d rather watch a book/write probably).
Shrek 3: -recoils in utter horror-
Shrek 4: Certainly better than the abysmal Shrek 3, though it may have been helped by the fact I hadn’t high expectations due to said horrifying sequel- and has good touching moments at points etc. But would have probably worked better as a premise for an ORIGINAL movie than say a shrek sequel (someone not appreciating what they have etc before its gone- Kind of like the Incredibles but not etc since Bob also got his hero work back. Could still even be fantasy based in a way if they’d wanted it.)
So… if we’re being nice maybe 2 out of 4?
(Though wait, weren’t there other Shrek sequels? Wasn’t there some terrible Christmas one or something? And something else? Hopefully the 4th will be the last)
I kind of want Pixar, once M.I.2 is done (…and hopefully it’s good too) however to go after Brave, produce more original movies for a little while. Like the next 5 or so movies. It’s just a fact however that sequels are more likely to -go- wrong or be more harshly criticised because they have to be both different and not simply a repeat of the original source… but still make sense in the context of the original in terms of both characters and world- in an original movie, something doesn’t work? You can reject it completely and start again even if you want to! You can pull 180s on a characters originally designed personality and scrap the original if you want the plot to go a certain way too. (As long as you’re not too far along I guess). You have more choice in originals to go in various directions- even if you still have some constraints of course.
With this many sequels, Dreamworks is going to perhaps commit ‘suicide’ in a way. Because if that’s all they’ll produce, why will anyone want to go back or watch them until they stop? After the 5th sequel (and that’s being optimistic), hardly anyone will care. It isn’t Harry Potter after all.
Shame. They were beginning to do things so well too in some respects.
They weren’t copying Pixar- but they were managing to gain a foothold in emotional films, while still maintaining their own flavour at the same time even if things weren’t always entirely smooth. (KFP, HTTYD and MM- the latter of which I’ve yet to see but hear good things about. .).